North Carolina Grays Flag Conserved for Future Generations

by Rick Walton, 6th North Carolina State Troops Historian


Saturday, September 7, 2024- In February 2015, the membership of the Cedar Fork Rifles Preservation Society, Inc (i. e. the 6th North Carolina State Troops Reenactors) decided to undertake the effort to raise the funds to conserve the silk company flag of the North Carolina Grays, currently stored in the inventory of the North Carolina Museum of History. This company became Company I of the 6th North Carolina State Troops, who we proudly portray as reenactors.

At the time, it seemed like an almost impossible task, given that the estimated total needed was nearly $14,000 for the conservation of a silk flag. Considering how much effort and time went into managing the fund raising for the now successful Sailors Creek Battle Flag conservation, a cotton flag requiring $6,500 and taking nearly three years, it was a leap of faith to undertake a project more than twice as costly. We kicked off the campaign with money in the left over from our Sailor's Creek project and forged ahead. 

Starting in 2015, we slowly crept toward our goal, raising our total to $6000 by late 2018. The 26th NCT Reactivated announced in 2019 that they would take the N.C. Grays flag as their next preservation effort and joined with us to complete the  fund raising which was accomplished by early 2023, sending this relic to be conserved.



On Saturday, September 7, 2024 the conserved flag was unveiled at a dedication ceremony at the North Carolina Museum of History before a mixed crowd of reenactors, historians and well-wishers.

The following is the Keynote address and slide show presented by Historian Rick Walton that will explain the interesting history of this unique flag.

Author, Rick Walton, with North Carolina Grays Flag

He Once Was lost, But Now He's Found- Finding Corporal Alburto L. Poteet

(c)2024 By Researcher and Historian for the 6th North Carolina State Troops- Frederick Walton
Collecting remains of killed at Cold Harbor for re-internment
 Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division Washington, D.C. 20540 USA
LC-DIG-ppmsca-35035 

Finding a missing Flag

 The other day, a Facebook Post popped up with a memory from Sept 4, 2012. In it, I announced to my friends and comrades that I had discovered a "missing" flag belonging to the 6th North Carolina State Troops that had recently been conserved and was on display at Gettysburg.

I had read about this in the 8/30/2012 edition of the “Hanover Evening Sun”. I don't recall now how I first stumbled upon this article, but I know I was very excited to find it. I probably found it by my routine searching of the internet for items related to the 6th North Carolina State Troops at lunch time.

The article explained that the Gettysburg National Military Park Museum and Visitor Centerwas becoming more dynamic,rotating exhibits and acquiring new and borrowed artifacts.

"The new exhibits also will include an artifact from the Robert E. Lee Memorial Foundation in Virginia. A flag representing the 6th North Carolina that was carried during the Battle of Gettysburg is on loan from its former home in Stratford Hall, the birthplace of Robert E. Lee."

Here is what I wrote to Facebook: 

"I have learned that the Gettysburg National Military Park Museum and Visitor Center has acquired a battle-flag carried by the 6th N.C. during the battle of Gettysburg. I have contacted curators to determine the provenance and learn whether this flag was carried by the 6th NC State Troops or the 6th NC Volunteers. This may be the "missing Flag" I have long talked about!"


Chris Pelletier uses a level to straighten the Confederate flag he had just finished hanging at the Gettysburg National Military Park Visitor Center Thursday. The flag was flown at the Battle of Gettysburg by the 6th North Carolina.

The 6th North Carolina State Troops was mustered on May 16, 1861. They were among the first ten regiments raised by the state of North Carolina, originally intended for the defense of the State. These regiments were equipped, trained, and ready for action and were the first troops consigned to the Confederate Government.

At the same time additional volunteer regiments "re-used" State Troop regimental numbers and had to be renumbered later. For example the 6th NC volunteers eventually was renumbered to the 16th North Carolina Troops. I have often found the 16th NCT referred to as the 6th NC Vols so this distinction must always be cleared up when researching. 

To make matters more confusing, the 6th North Carolina State Troops, The 6th North CarolinaVolunteers (16th NC Troops), and sometimes even the Sixth North Carolina Cavalry(65th NC Troops) are often denoted simply as the 6th NC! 

If you are doing research on an ancestor and their regiment is 1-10 NC "Volunteers", simply add 10 to get the final regimental designation as 11-20 NC "Troops".

This article launched a lot of letter writing, research and documentation that eventually established the provenance of the flag carried by the 6th North Carolina State Troops.

Stratford Hall object number 1981.096.

The Flag is owned by Stratford Hall, Robert E. Lee Memorial Association, Stratford Virginia. Stratford Hall object number 1981.096. It is On Loan to the Gettysburg National Military Park Museum and Visitor Center 

The battle flag is a third bunting issue, Army of Northern Virginia Battle flag made of wool and cotton. It is attributed to the Richmond Depot circa 1862. It was carried by the 6th North Carolina State Troops at Gettysburg.

Battle honors include Manassas, Malvern Hill and Eltham's landing, Seven Pines and Gaines Mill, all of which help narrow down the potential unit owning this particular flag since there is no unit number painted on it.

On July 25th, 1862, after the Peninsular Campaign, General W. H. C. Whiting, commanding the Third Brigade, issued General orders number 88 directing:

“The regiments of the five brigades of this division now present will have inscribed on their battle flag the names, “Seven Pines, Gaines Farm & Malvern Hill.” In addition to the above the regts of the Texas Brigade, The Hampton Legion & the 6th N. C. will have the word Eltham’s Landing put on their colors & all the regiments of the 3d. Brigade including the Legion the word Manassas.”

Here was the real Clue! Per Whitings directive ONLY the Texas Brigade, the Hampton Legion and the 6th N. C.S.T. would have the battle honor for Eltham's Landing.
Research showed that the ONLY flag unaccounted for was that of the 6th North Carolina, so BINGO, we have a match.

Author Rick Walton in 2014, pointing to the Battle Honor that proved the provenance of this flag

Two years later I journeyed to Gettysburg and had the opportunity to view this flag up close. As the historian for the 6th North Carolina State Troops it gave me great pleasure to have "discovered" this lost flag. I am grateful to all the flag experts at Gettysburg and elsewhere that did the real footwork to prove the provenance and give us a glimpse of the actual flag carried on the battlefield at Gettysburg.

Camp Jones

 On August 3, 1861,  Confederate soldiers, belonging to the brigades of Brig. Gens. Henry Whiting and Cadmus Wilcox, arrived from the devastated battlefields of Manassas to the pristine acres surrounding Bristoe Station.  

Historical marker for CAMP JONES

This encampment was named Camp Jones after Col. Egbert Jones of the 4th Alabama Infantry, who died from wounds suffered at the First Battle of Manassas. These rolling hills  served as an ideal location for a large encampment, as it was near the fresh water source of the Broad River and close to the vital Orange and Alexandria Railroad. Camp Jones probably consisted of numerous unit encampments spread out around the Bristoe Station area. Sadly little is known about this camp, it's layout, it's hospitals and it's cemeteries today. 

We know that the Sixth North Carolina State Troops marched here on this date, because they told us ...in their muster roster descriptions, like this one from Co. 

Co. I, 6th Regiment North Carolina Infantry

Company Muster Roll for  June 20 to Aug 31, 1861 

“Marched to Camp Jones 8 miles distant 3 August, 1861."

Captain Benjamin F. White recorded his first impressions in his diary on August 3rd:

Saturday, August 3, 1861


Received orders to have tents struck half past five A. M. About seven set out for a new encampment on Broad run near to, and South North of Bristol Station. Encamped in a beautiful place. Water good. Soil in the vicinity pretty good. Night Edward Pace and seven of others pretty sick a number of sick men staying in the officers tents.

Poor sanitary conditions in the camps led to a massive outbreak of various diseases that resulted in nearly 1,000 deaths. Soldiers died from ailments such as yellow fever, dysentery, typhoid, measles and other contagious diseases. Most of these men were buried in various cemeteries organized by their state of origin. There are at least 2 Dozen members of the Sixth North Carolina State Troops that died here. Some were shipped home for burial, but many were buried in Camp Jones in a cemetery whose location is today unknown. 

Reverend John Archibald McMannen 

The Rev. John A. McMannen, a frequent visitor to the camp, recorded his observations about the regimental cemetery in a newspaper letter to the The Hillsborough Recorder on Wednesday, October 23, 1861:

"...When I left before, (Camp Jones,) there was not less than six hundred sick men, of this number, twenty died in camp. They are buried side by side, in a lovely spot, on the summit of a lofty hill. The graves are done up with care and neatness, a head and foot-board with the name, regiment, &c, designate who they are.


They are surrounded by a neat enclosure. As I gazed on these twenty graves, memory called up from the past many pleasant reminiscences of by-gone days far back when the war hung below the horizon, and the horrors of the battle-field had not been thought of. By my own fire- side I had warmed some of them, and in their youthful company had spent many happy hours. The words of their lips still rung in my ears, and the pleasant smile still played on their faces. 


But, alas I stand now by the grave of McKee, and next lo his is Berry's, and there is Hix's, and yonder young Lawrence sleeps. My heart was filled, but tears came to my relief."

Those mentioned are:

  • McKee- Pvt. John K. McKee, Co. B, Age 22 D. 9/24/1861; 
  • Berry- Pvt Robert Berry, Co. B, Age 17, D. 9/22/1861; 
  • Hix- Pvt. James Hicks, Co. C, Age 47, D. 9/10/1861;  
  • Lawrence- Pvt. M. B. Lawrence, Co. I, Age 21, D. 9/30/1861

by Septemnber 18, 1861 The pristine rolling hills had become contaminated with death and disease. The Sixth North Carolina State Troops moved on to Camp Fisher near Dumfries, where they found a clean, pleasant camp ground as well as new military duties guarding the Potomac river.  

Camp Jones and Bristoe State had not seen the end of the war and would host both Confederate and Federal encampments as well as several battles before the war was over. These actions would serve to erase the earlier camp, leaving its location somewhat of a mystery today. There is a battlefield park in the general location, but hard boundaries no longer exist


Colonel Pender

Colonel Dorsey Pender, the newly appointed Colonel for the Sixth North Carolina State Troops recalled his first impressions on arriving at Camp Jones:

"I find the health of the Reg. terrible. Only about two hundred and thirty fit for duty and many of the sick desperately ill. I fear we shall have a great many deaths before we get through. And accommodations are adverse, worse than on march. I shall do all in my power to relieve these poor fellows… — Col. Willam Dorsey Pender, Camp Jones, Near Manassas, August 27, 1861"

 

Baptism of Blood

The Sixth North Carolina at 1st Manassas 
 

Researched and written by Historian Frederick Walton

Copyright © 2001, 2023 By Frederick Walton

Confederate troops boarding the train at Piedmont Station en route to Manassas

It was not too many years ago that any schoolboy or girl could have told you the story of the battle of 1st Manassas. Even a child could see the irony of the southern citizen soldiers  who gathered on the plains of Manassas with their faces toward an invading northern army and their backs to the  homes and hearths that they vowed to protect. This is a classic David and Goliath story, right against might, a story of how stout-hearted Confederates, against overwhelming odds were able to turn the tables on an over-confident enemy and send them running back to Washington, D.C. in a panic stricken and confused  rout.

But, there is another story to be told within the context of this larger tale. The story of the only North Carolina Regiment in the fight that day. The story of  brothers fighting with brothers against a common enemy. The story of how fate took these North Carolinians from their post in the Shenandoah Valley to the left of the beleaguered Confederate line at just the right moment to save Stonewall’s legendary counter charge from certain destruction under the unseen guns of a lone Federal Battery waiting on their flank.

Many of the young men from North Carolina never returned home from this moment of glory, and history has overlooked their critical contribution to the pivotal event of the battle. This is a story to commemorate the sacrifices of those brave North Carolinians so long ago.       

 Levi Festerman awoke with a start as the laboring steam engine lurched around a bend. His fitful sleep was disturbed once again as he clung to the roof of the rattling car until his fingers tingled with numbness. Last night's excitement, when finally boarding the train for the battlefront, was now a distant, weary memory. The exhausted soldiers inside the train began to feel crushed and claustrophobic as the hot, muggy air seemed to press in on their crowded compartment. On top of the train, windblown soldiers held on for dear life as the rickety train hurtled through the darkness into the unknown. In the ensuing silence, as even the more boisterous fell silent, terror began to invade the thoughts of the citizen soldiers. They recalled tales they had heard about loyal unionists who had been known to put obstructions on the rails that could send the precariously perched soldiers to their deaths. 

 Sparks from the locomotive streaked brightly through the darkness, masking imagined bushwhackers around every bend. The night sounds were lost to the clicking of the rails and the roar of the engine. The crowded roof constantly shifted as the train bucked and lurched. Hot embers from the engine stung as they flew into Levi's face, burning little holes in his new uniform. The early morning wind was surprisingly cool.  

The men had eagerly boarded the train about 7 p.m. on the 20th of July 1861, excited about the prospect of going to Manassas junction and being part of the big fight commencing there. After an exhausting forced march left them worn out and hungry, they had been waiting all day to board the cars. In her diary, Ida Powell Delaney recorded the scene at Piedmont Station: 

"The many soldiers scattered about in groups, sleeping, cooking, eating and talking, waiting for the cars to take them to meet the enemy, seemed like sheep gathered for the slaughter, and my heart ached to look at them." 

But the men, although tired and hungry, shared no such thoughts. They felt more like caged animals worried about their prospects of getting to Manassas before the battle was over and the South won the "war" without them.  
 
For the Sixth North Carolina State Troops, a train derailment that afternoon was a blessing in disguise. The Colonel, Charles F. Fisher, was the president of the North Carolina railroad, and many of his men were former railroad workers he had recruited when he formed the regiment. He volunteered the know-how of these railroad men to set the train back on the track. It’s not known if he made their immediate passage a part of the bargain, but  their hard labor was rewarded by jumping ahead of the other troops waiting and getting on the very cars they righted.  Some of the tired men including Levi Festerman of company G, climbed on top of the cars while others pushed into the stuffy, crowded interior.  An air of excitement and jubilation prevailed as the young men were finally off to war…and glory. 

Early the next morning Levi focused his weary eyes on the eastern horizon. The light from the rising sun streaked across the gray dawn sky. Without even thinking about it, a lifetime of farming permitted him to read the weather and told him this would be another hot day. 
 
Miles away, on the Northern side of the Bull Run, Federal troops, who had been awakened at 2:00 a.m., wearily marched into position as they approached the Confederate picket lines. They were store clerks and salesmen who had responded to Lincoln's call to suppress the rebellion. Their commander, General Irwin McDowell, was not yet confident of their abilities and only sent them toward the Confederates upon the urging of the President, Abraham Lincoln. When McDowell complained that his troops were inexperienced and needed more time for training, his superior, General Scott, responded by reminding him: 
"You are green, it is true, but they are green also; you are all green alike." 
 General Winfield Scott Circa 1862
(LOC LOT 14043-2, no. 914 [P&P])

McDowell’s plan was simple. Send a diversionary force to demonstrate near the Stone Bridge, the logical approach to Manassas from his stronghold at Centerville, while sending his main body far to the right around the Confederate flank, crossing the Bull Run upstream at the unprotected Sudley ford. 

At 6:00 a.m. a monstrous thirty-pounder Parrot rifle of Federal General Tyler’s Brigade belched forth three missiles from a protected place half a mile away from the Stone Bridge, on the Warrenton turnpike, indicating the beginning of the battle. One of these shells, aimed at a signal station, knocked down the tent of young E. Porter Alexander. Perched high in the air on his makeshift tower, he trained his glass toward the Stone Bridge to observe the activity there. As they continued firing, the Federals were frustrated by the fact that the Confederates neither ran off in terror nor betrayed their position on the opposite bank of the Bull Run. Around 8:30 a.m., Alexander's well trained eyes noticed a momentary flash in the distance. It was the early morning sunlight flashing off a polished brass cannon barrel. Later recalling it as "indescribably quick", it drew his attention to Sudley ford, some eight miles distant from the signal station, where he noticed "the glitter of bayonets all along a road crossing the valley". He realized McDowell's plan and quickly signaled Colonel Evans, at the left end of the Confederate line to "look out for your left, you are flanked", spoiling the Federal's element of surprise. Evans moved a portion of his force to meet the Yankee threat on the flank and was soon engaged in a battle on Matthew's hill that would last all morning, drawing Confederate manpower away from General P. T. G. Beauregard's carefully placed defenses. Beauregard had spent the last month meticulously planning this battle and it was already off to a disastrous start.  

General Joseph E. Johnston

The Sixth North Carolina was still many miles distant as the battle commenced. Between the violent lurching of the train and the frequent stops for fuel, water and maintenance it seemed like they would never arrive. As they drew near the junction at Manassas they could hear the booming rumble of artillery and the muffled, far off crackling of musketry fire. On the horizon, great clouds of smoke and dust boiled over the treetops marking the fierce battle being fought below. 

Their journey really began several weeks before when they left the training grounds in Richmond, where President Davis himself had come out to review them. They boarded cars north to Manassas Junction and then Piedmont station, marching the final 18 miles to Winchester.  They were joining General Joseph E. Johnston's army of the Shenandoah and were brigaded under General Bernard Bee. Lt. Willie P. Mangum of company B recalled: 
"We all suffered much from fatigue and want of food and the bad weather. But soldiers must become accustomed to privations." 
This would be the beginning of four years of privations for many of the men. Others would not live beyond this battle.
 
General Pierre Gustave Toutant-Beauregard

On the evening of July 18th General Joseph E. Johnston had personally spoken to the regiment, telling them they were going to Manassas to help General Beauregard, who was under attack by the Yankees.  The enthusiastic and untested  young men responded with a loud and lusty cheer. They were soon on the march, retracing their steps of a few days before, back to Piedmont station. Amanda Virginia Edwards watched the dusty columns passing by Belle Grove near Paris, Virginia.

 "Our dear, worn, fatigued soldiers. O! What is it that we wouldn't do for them. Regiment after Regiment pass by... "Dixie" is the national and favorite air. Many are singing, laughing and chatting in perfectly good spirits, just ready and willing for a fight. You never suppose that an idea of getting killed ever entered their heads. Poor creatures-- how many will march to their graves. Some are dear little boys between fifteen and sixteen years old and others are grey headed." 

Now that they had finally arrived, their help was desperately needed. It was about sunrise when they finally got off the trains. They marched four miles, toward the Lewis house and the sounds of the battle already under way. Captain York wrote to the North Carolina Standard after the battle that the terrible cannonading "nerved every arm, brightened every eye and quickened every step." The regiment had been without food and had little sleep for over thirty hours. When a spring was reached the companies were filed left and allowed to fill their canteens. Twenty three year old Levi and many of his tired comrades sunk down in the cool  shadows of the surrounding grove and promptly fell asleep while their pards replenished their canteens. One account indicates that they were halted and "drilled in the manual" for an hour,  before continuing their march to the battlefield. Most accounts place their time of arrival on the battlefield at about 2:00 P.M. Colonel Fisher pushed on ahead going to the Lewis house to meet General Johnston and receive his orders. The tired men of the Sixth were ordered to "load" and then fell out under cover of a hill behind the line of Confederate guns near the Lewis house, "Portici", being used by Johnston as his headquarters. Many of them promptly fell asleep on their loaded arms, even with the sound of the battle exploding all around  them. Missiles whizzed through the trees above their heads, sending limbs and leaves fluttering into their midst. Deprived of sleep for three days, the men barely moved. 

The Lewis House Portici (LOC LC-DIG-ppmsca-20479.jpg)

Suddenly a "slug" from a rifled cannon came tumbling into the ranks parting Captain Craig's  G company. Another struck Colonel Fisher's Horse, slightly injuring  it. Wounded Confederates began appearing from the battlefield, staggering toward the rear. The eager young lads of the Sixth regiment were seeing the bloody result of the fighting, their first glimpse of war, real war. This was no longer a fanciful, storybook daydream. They were no longer chivalrous knights in long plumbed hats. Men were dying this day.  Lieutenant (later Captain) Ray, from Company D, recalled seeing wounded men coming through the ranks and wrote 
"some of our men were so unsoldierly as to envy those who had escaped with only such slight wounds as would give them a furlough" 


Colonel Fisher

Colonel Fisher ordered the gawking boys into line, knowing he might lose control  of his frightened green troops if he didn't act quickly. What happened next, while not precisely clear, was reported on by dozens of eyewitnesses in letters, newspapers and memoirs.  
Lieutenant (later Captain) B. F. White, of company F,  recalled  
"Lieutenant-Colonel  Lightfoot requested Major R. F. Webb to ask, for him, the privilege of putting the regiment in line of battle, as Colonel Fisher had not drilled the regiment and was incompetent to do it, and further that Colonel Fisher and himself were not on good terms" 
 Colonel Fisher refused this request and ordered the regiment forward, hurrying toward the threatened left of the Confederate line.  
After a mid-day  lull in the battle, McDowell had ordered  Rickett's battery to the top of Henry hill where they quickly became engaged in an "exceedingly hot" dual with the Washington Artillery and other Confederate batteries, firmly planted on the opposite crest.  General Thomas J. Jackson, about to earn his nickname, "Stonewall", was calmly moving fresh troops of infantry into position behind the booming artillery.

 On the left of the Federal line, Griffin's Battery limbered up its two howitzers and galloped furiously behind Rickett's guns to "a less exposed" position. Reaching the Sudley road  he turned left , went down the road a short distance and then abruptly turned left again, reentering the field looking down the flank of the Confederate Guns. 

Griffin's Battery at Manassas Battlefield (Photo by Frederick Walton)

Nearby, the 33rd Virginia watched in amazement as the Federal gunners unlimbered and boldly set about their deadly business, seemingly unconcerned that the blue clad Confederates were massing nearby. Mistaking the Virginians for their artillery support, the gunners allowed them to advance to within 40 yards before the battery fell victim to a devastating volley. 

The 14th Brooklyn, known as the red-legged devils because of the baggy red Zouave pants they wore, rushed forward through the retreating artillerymen and unleashed a volley into the 33rd Virginia, crumbling their line and retaking Griffin's Battery. Supported by Minnesota troops, the Zouaves continued their advance pouring volleys into the crippled flank of the Confederate left. This put the Confederate line in a precarious position.


The Sixth North Carolina was close by, still moving toward the left. They had gone down a hill,  passing through some woods, before emerging into an old sedge field. They crossed a small stream, halting for a short time.  Heading toward a point to the rear of where Colonel Bartow fell earlier. A  mounted Confederate warned Fisher not to go in that direction to avoid being cut up by Yankee Cavalry. Fisher turned the Regiment abruptly left, crossed an old worm fence and passed through a thick Pine wood in the rear of the fourth Alabama, 2nd Mississippi & 2 companies of the 11th Miss. An old farm road  could be seen disappearing into the woods. Fisher turned right, again heading toward the left of the Confederate line. Following the road, keeping a thick copse of wood  to his  left, they emerged from the pines beyond the Mississippi troops. 

Remains of the Old farm Road at Manassas Battlefield Park (Photo by Frederick Walton)

When the right of the 6th North Carolina State Troops got opposite the left of the Mississippi Regiment , Captain White recalled
 "I heard distinctly one of our field officers call to Colonel Fisher, "Colonel, turn the head of your regiment this way" To this Colonel Fisher paid no attention whatever, but passed on into an angle formed by the Yankees in the Sudley road and the New York Zouaves marching to turn our left flank." 

When the left of the third company, company F, commanded by 1st Lt. Robert N. Carter came opposite of the Mississippi Regiment, one of the field officers yelled halt. Carter repeated the commanded and added "Right Face". Colonel Fisher was a short distance away and "called out sharply, "Who in the hell gave that command? I am the Colonel of this Regiment; follow me."" Carter corrected the command by saying "left face, Forward, March". Since no other company had halted, Co. F followed the two lead companies. "Lightfoot Remarked, "did any body ever see the like."  

With a sickening thud an unsuspecting soldier was thrown violently backward into his filemates before falling to the ground, shot in the head.  The sound of a volley  from an angle to their left echoed away,  passing  mostly  harmlessly over the heads of the surprised men. Before they could react a second and third volley came in lower and found their marks.  Captain York reported many of his injured men as being shot in the thigh. Lt. Colonel  Lightfoot was slightly wounded and according to Captain White,  
"headed toward the rear calling out "Boys, take care of yourselves"".  
Nearby, Captain Issac E. Avery's Company E had been halted directly in front of what they all believed to be Sherman's battery, only sixty  yards away. Staring down the twin dark throats of shiny brass howitzers, Captain Avery had  no time to wait for orders. Taking control of his company, he ordered his men to fire. His anxious men and others near them fired suddenly into the battery. A Thunderous volley killed most of the cannoneers as well as their horses. 
A Federal officer, thinking they were a Federal battery support, galloped up, waving his hat and calling "For Gods sake stop; you are firing on your friends". Discovering his almost fatal mistake too late, he attempted to ride off but reeled and fell as he passed the left of the adjacent Mississippi Regiment and was captured. He was Colonel Orlando B. Willcox, 1st Michigan who afterwards became a Major-General. General Clingman from North Carolina recalled that Colonel Liddell of the 11th Miss. got his horse  "and rode him for many a day". 

Another section of the Sixth had focused their fire on  the unseen riflemen to their left that were firing into their flank. Witnesses latter speculated that this may have been the 4th Alabama. As the smoke of  the unordered volley drifted over the carnage around the battery, seven of Fisher's companies ran forward firing at will. Three other companies who were not clear of the woods didn't get into the fight, although their ranks were raked with small arms fire. Witnessing this desperate charge, General Clingman later recalled that 

"The men ran down upon them and finished the survivors with their muskets and bowie knifes." 

The wide battle line became a confused mob as the flank companies focused on the battery in the center and  began a pursuit of the retreating Yankees. The momentum of the charge carried the line beyond the disabled battery toward the Sudley Road , Where it  was subjected to a heavy fire from Yankees stationed in the road and New York Zouaves, in bright red trousers, on the left. 

In the confusing melee, the Sixth was taking fire from all directions, Officers were desperately shouting for the men to stop "firing on your friends". Men fell dead and wounded across the crest of the hill. Exposed to a  raking crossfire Fisher had no other choice but to order his men to retreat, which Captain York recalled was done "with some disorder". 


 On the far right of the line, in a grove of trees, Lt. Mangum was leading his men forward when he fell stunned. A bullet had hit the bible in his breast pocket that his sister had presented him when he departed. Saving him from instant death, the bullet glanced off  "inflicting a severe, but not dangerous flesh wound". Poor medical treatment caused complications and several weeks later he died as the result of his wounds.  

(Today a marker commemorates where he fell). 

Lt. William Preston Mangum, 6th North Carolina State Troops

Marker on Manassas Battlefield (Photo By Frederick Walton)

Captain Avery recalled seeing Colonel Fisher fall  as he was rallying his men according to a report by General Clingman:

"Captain Issac Avery stated to me that while he was sitting for a moment on one of the captured pieces, he saw Colonel Fisher, who had moved forward to reconnoitre seemingly, but was waving his rifle above his head triumphantly. "

"having passed over the battery, [Fisher] received a ball in the brain and fell dead about thirty yards in the rear of the battery they had taken."

A witness reported his last words to be "fire on the battery".  He fell, shot through the head by a single bullet. After the battle there was much controversy over where the projectile originated. In the confusion of the charge, some believe it may have come from Confederates. Avery believed it came from a Massachusetts regiment wearing gray that was posted near the Sudley road. Fishers death was lamented throughout the south as that of a brave and noble patriot. The young Rowan county farm boy, Levi Festerman,  wrote to his family: 
"We had a hard time here last Sunday... Our Colonel was too brave and rushed in too strong. The Colonel hollowed hurrah Rowan boys and kept rallying them up. It is a wonder we wasn't all killed  the way we was led into it. The Colonel must have been excited the way he went on, but the poor fellow lost his life by the operation." 
Making their way to the relatively safe fringe of pine, where they launched their original attack, the surviving officers of the 6th North Carolina State Troops attempted to restore order to the tangled and confused  knot of soldiers. As a fragile line formed, Captain Avery looked across the hillside scattered with dead and wounded comrades and noticed old glory still floating over the disabled battery. Determined to claim the battery, he ordered another charge and his men went forward into the whirlwind of bullets surrounding the guns. Moving quickly, his men drove off the remaining defenders and once again took the disputed  battery. Perhaps not realizing the success of this charge, and hidden by the   smoke of the battlefield, an eyewitness reported the Sixth North Carolina being fired on by Mississippi and South Carolina Brigades as well as the Federals in their front. 

Pressured to once again leave this murderous position, The gallant Sixth was compelled to abandon the hard won guns. Guns that could have devastated the fragile Confederate line. Guns that were never fired again that day as a result of the North Carolinian's charge.  

It can not be disputed that this charge was a turning point in the battle. Had Griffin's battery gotten established in this position, it would have enfiladed the Confederate line, forcing them off Henry hill as they had been pushed off of Mathews hill during the morning battle. 

"Stonewall" Jackson may have never earner his moniker if the 6th North Carolina State Troops had not stopped Griffin's Battery from Flanking him and his Virginians.

Captain Ricketts, who was captured, told Colonel Waightsill Avery  (Captain I. E. Avery's brother) That "the position of Fisher's Regiment was such that he supposed them to be a support for his battery". He recalled that all his men were killed or wounded by the Sixth and had he a minutes time longer he might have swept the whole head of the column down. 
As Fishers men blunted the effects of Griffin's  Battery, the entire Confederate line began moving forward, pushing the remaining Federals off of Henry hill and turning what might have been a disaster for the young Confederate cause into a rout. Fishers men had done their duty well, but as they reorganized their lines in the shadows of the pines, other southern troops had moved forward, and again "captured" the disabled battery, littered with the bodies of Yankee cannoneers, North Carolinians of the Sixth regiment  and dead horses still in their harnesses, holding the caissons fast to that position. 

Members of the 6th North Carolina State Troops reenactors at  
the 140th anniversary of the battle of 1st Manassas in 2001

The Surviving members of the Sixth North Carolina State Troops moved forward in the wake of the attacking Confederate line, driving the demoralized Yankees before them, down the sloops of Henry hill, through the fields bordering the Bull Run and finally across the stone bridge toward Centerville. As the shadows grew longer, the exhausted men gave up the chase and spent the night sleeping on the vast battlefield. Hopelessly  mixed up with other Confederate troops that only hours before may have been inadvertently firing on them as they surrounded the captured battery. 

Captain B. F. White

Captain White recalled that when the Sixth finally halted for the night and roll call was taken only 125 men were present. The fast moving battle had scattered the rest. They drifted back to camp from advanced positions on the battlefield removing the concern that the regiment had been wiped out. In the end 25 men from the Sixth were killed and double that number were wounded. Private Festerman survived the battle only to be slightly wounded a week later when a gun accidentally discharged in camp. (Levi would fight with the Sixth for two more years before being wounded at Gettysburg and captured on South Mountain.) 

Colonel Charles Frederick  Fisher, a gallant leader with a  promising future, was cut down by a single minie ball.  Many of the field officers, including Avery and Lightfoot were also wounded. The Sixth North Carolina had fought valiantly in their first battle. 

Colonel Fisher Fell about where the Flag pole stands at the Manassas Battlefield Visitor Center
(photo by Frederick Walton)

The following week as newspapers across the south celebrated the great victory, a dispute arose about "who captured Sherman's battery" the accomplished and feared 'regular army' cannoneers. Various regiments claimed the honor as their own. Much newsprint was dedicated to the debate. General Clingman implored General  Johnston to set the record straight, but Johnston slyly avoided the controversy by claiming he could only share what was submitted to him by his subordinates. At this time he was more concerned with his own place in history as he struggled to publicize his leadership role which both General Beauregard and President Davis were anxious to claim as well. 

Regrettably Colonel Fisher did not live to write the account of the glorious charge and claim for the Sixth North Carolina the credit they deserved. Lt. Colonel Lightfoot, for reasons not recorded for historians, refused to submit a report. General Clingman, trying to defend North Carolina's honor many years later wrote: 

"Lt. Colonel Lightfoot "with the two rear companies, was by some means separated from the balance of the regiment ." The officers stated that while under his immediate command, as the regiment was marching forward into battle, they were separated from the other eight companies. Lightfoot, in their presence, for it was a general conversation,  complained very much of Colonel Fisher because he carried the regiment into action by the flank"  He refused  to submit a report, not having  been in the battle himself."  

 Lightfoot was an unpopular officer and was not appointed to colonel of the Sixth Regiment after Fisher's death. 

Quartermaster, Lieutenant Nathaniel E. Scales, recalled in his memoirs :

"The lieutenant colonel, Charles E. Lightfoot, would naturally have been made colonel, but although a most excellent drill officer, very popular, after the battle made many unkind remarks about Colonel Fisher, laying all the blame upon him for the loss of his own life and the men on the right.

We officers resented this and some 12 or 15 of us met one evening in my tent to talk it over. We wrote to the governor of North Carolina [Governor Henry Toole Clark], who made the appointments in the state troop regiments, and asked him to give us a North Carolina man for colonel."

Colonel Pender, A North Carolinian and Already the Colonel of the 13th North Carolina Regiment was appointed as the New Colonel Of the Sixth North Carolina State Troops. Lightfoot was a strict disciplinarian and in the days after the battle, the men of the Sixth struggled with a new enemy- sickness and disease, shortages of food and clothing, poor living conditions and low moral.  Lightfoot ignored the hardships being faced instead renewing his military school notions on the men who were increasingly losing their respect for the drill master. 

Colonel Pender despaired over the sickness and low moral writing:

"I never saw such long faces as when I came here. Together with sickness and misdirected discipline one never heard a good laugh of an attempt at song"

 Realizing the hatred Lightfoot was breeding, Colonel Pender reprimanded him for his pompous attitude, further alienating his second in command.

Less than a year later Lieutenant Colonel Lightfoot transferred to the 22nd North Carolina Infantry Regiment Volunteers to become its colonel.

Captain Robert F. Webb

On July 22,1861 Captain Robert F. Webb, commanding the Flat River Guards, company B wrote to Hon. W. P. Magnum, Lt. Magnum's father, informing him of his sons wounding. his closing lines clarified what the his son and the 6th regiment had accomplished:

"I can testify to his gallantry, he was one of the few who charged Sherman's battery, and took it. He was standing by me when he was shot...the guns captured by our men are not certain to be Shermans [latter shown to be Griffin's] but we took the guns!"

The North Carolina Standard had the final say in a  short editorial comment several weeks after the battle. "Who took Sherman's Battery?" read the headline.  Their claim was short and to the point. "Well we know who took Rickett's battery, Colonel Fishers North Carolinians!  Any comments?" 
  

Sources:
Clark, Walter, Histories of the several Regiments and Battalions from North Carolina in the great War 1861-'65, Wilmington, N.C.: Broadfoot PublishingCo., 1991

Davis, William C., Battle at Bull Run, Garden City, New York: Doubleday & Company, 1977

Davis, William C. and the Editors of Time-Life Books, First Blood: Fort Sumpter to Bull Run, Alexandria, Va.: Time Life Books, 1983

Hanson, Joseph Mills, Bull Run Remembers..., Chelsea, MI: BookCrafters, 1951 & 1991

Hennessy, John, The First Battle Of Manassas: An End to Innocence, July 18-21, 1861, Lynchburg, Va.: H.E. Howard, Inc., 1989

Iobst, Richard W., The Bloody Sixth: The Sixth Carolina Regiment Confederate States of America, Raleigh, N.C.: North Carolina Division of Archives and History, 1965

Jordon, Weymouth T. (editor), North Carolina Troops, 1861-65, Raleigh, N.C.: NC Dept. Of Archives and History, 1981 

McDonald, JoAnna M., "We Shall Meet Again":The First Battle of Manassas (Bull Run) July 18-21, 1861, Shippensburg, Pa.: White Mane Books, 1999 


Shanks, Thomas Henry (ed.), "The papers of Willie Person Magnum", Durham , N. C.:Christian Printing Co. (for State (N. C.) Dept of History and Archives), 1956

Warder, T. B. & Catlett, Jas. M., Battle of Youngs Branch or Manassas Plain: Fought July 21, 1861, Richmond: Enquirer Book and Job Press, 1862 (Prince William County Historical Society Reprint)

Wheeler, Richard, A Rising Thunder: From Lincoln's Election to the Battle of Bull Run: An Eyewitness History, New York: HarpersCollins Publishers Inc., 1994 


News papers and Documents


North Carolina Standard July 27; July 31; August 3; August 7; August 10, 1861 

The North Carolina Weekly State Journal, Raleigh, NC September 4, 1861 


Greensboro Daily News December 28,1921

Manassas National Battlfield Park Archives: Letter from Levi A. Festerman to parents on 7/24/61

North Carolina Grays Flag Conserved for Future Generations

by Rick Walton, 6th  North Carolina State Troops Historian Saturday, September 7, 2024 - In February 2015, the membership of the Cedar Fork ...